Duby’s Bagels, Old Saybrook, Connecticut

đŸ„Ż Why Duby’s Bagels in Old Saybrook Might Be the Best Bagels in Connecticut

If you’ve ever found yourself craving a real New York–style bagel along the Connecticut shoreline, you’re not alone. And if you haven’t yet made your way to Duby’s Bagels & Bakery in Old Saybrook, consider this your nudge.

At the heart of the bakery is Duby himself—a passionate baker with a deep respect for tradition and a serious love for great bagels. Drawing inspiration from classic New York-style baking, Duby set out to bring something truly authentic to the Connecticut shoreline, and he’s done exactly that. Every bagel reflects his dedication to craft—hand-rolled, boiled, and baked just the way they should be. But what really sets Duby apart is his presence in the shop. He’s often behind the counter, greeting customers with a smile, swapping stories, and making everyone feel like part of the family. It’s clear that for Duby, this isn’t just about bagels—it’s about community, care, and doing things the right way.

Located at 785 Boston Post Rd, this little shop is turning heads (and satisfying serious cravings) with their authentic, hand-rolled bagels that taste like they came straight from Brooklyn.

First Impressions

Walk into Duby’s on a weekend morning and you’ll likely find a line of regulars and first-timers buzzing with anticipation. The smell of fresh bagels and pastries hits you before you even step inside. It’s warm, cozy, and totally unpretentious—the kind of place where you feel instantly at home.

The staff is friendly, the coffee is hot, and the vibe? Think “neighborhood gem” with a dash of NYC soul.

The Bagels: Worth the Hype

Let’s talk about the main event: the bagels. These beauties are boiled and baked the traditional New York way—on burlap-covered cedar planks—and you can taste the difference. They’ve got that perfect balance of chewy exterior and fluffy interior, with a solid selection of flavors like plain, sesame, everything, poppy, and more.

Pro tip: grab an everything bagel with scallion cream cheese and thank me later. Or if you’re in the mood for something more substantial, try the Famous New Yawker—lox, cream cheese, capers, and red onion. It’s a classic, and Duby’s does it justice.

More Than Just Bagels

While the bagels are the star of the show, Duby’s also turns out some seriously delicious baked goods:

  • Buttery croissants
  • Rugelach that melts in your mouth
  • Soft, pillowy challah
  • Artisanal sourdough
  • Giant cookies and hearty muffins

They also serve local Ashlawn Farm Coffee and Harney & Sons teas, which makes it a great stop even if you’re just in the mood for a pastry and a hot drink.

And yes, they have online ordering, a rewards program, and they’re on Too Good To Go for end-of-day goodies. Major points for convenience and sustainability.

What People Are Saying

Don’t just take my word for it—Duby’s is getting love from all over. They’ve been featured in CT Magazine as one of the best bagel spots in the state, and customers on Reddit, Yelp, and Nextdoor all seem to agree:

“The shoreline is lucky to have these guys.”
“Legit NYC bagels in CT—finally!”
“Honestly, better than some bagels I’ve had in the city.”

The Verdict

Duby’s Bagels & Bakery is a true hidden gem. Whether you’re a bagel snob from the Bronx or just someone who knows a good thing when you taste it, you’re going to love what they’re serving up here. It’s easily one of the best spots for bagels—not just in Old Saybrook, but in all of Connecticut.

So the next time you’re nearby (or even if you’re not—it’s worth the trip), swing by, grab a bagel, and enjoy a little bite of New York right here on the shoreline.

Plan Your Visit:

📍 Duby’s Bagels & Bakery
785 Boston Post Rd, Old Saybrook, CT 06475
🕖 Open Wednesday–Sunday, 7 AM–2 PM
📞 (860) 339‑3014
🌐 www.dubysbagels.com